Send this news story to a friend
Northern Ireland’s Health Department's Guidelines on Abortion 'Seriously... : 20th Nov 08
An American-based academic has described Northern Ireland’s health department’s guidelines on abortion as “seriously misleading”. Professor John Keown of the Kennedy Institute of Ethics, Georgetown University, Washington DC, made his comments in response to a legal query by the Association of Catholic Lawyers of Ireland (ACLI).
Professor Keown referred to the consultation process begun in July by the North’s Department of Health to try to establish when abortions were legal in Northern Ireland. The 1967 British Abortion Act does not apply to Northern Ireland and the four main parties oppose its extension to the North. Under current legislation, according to the department, abortions are permitted in the North where “there is a threat to the life of the woman, or a risk of real and serious harm to her long-term or permanent health (physical or mental)”.
Professor Keown referred to the opening statement of the department’s guidance, which states “within the scope of this guidance and the law in Northern Ireland, each health and social services trust must ensure that its patients have access to termination of pregnancy services”. This was “seriously misleading”, he said.
“The starting point of the guidance should be a clear statement of the illegality of abortion in Northern Ireland: that it is a crime punishable by a maximum of life imprisonment to use any means with intent to procure miscarriage,” he added.“
The guidance should then recall the central if not sole purpose of this prohibition: the protection of the unborn child, a purpose that has informed the law against abortion for over 700 years. “Only when the rule has been stated should the scope of the exception be considered”, Professor Keown said. Barrister Johanna Higgins of ACLI said Prof Keown had underlined “a fundamental flaw” in the department’s guidelines. The Irish Times.
Recent Topics
- Medicines Board Exposes Irish Fertility Industry Fiascos That Trigger Embryo...
- Aborted Mums Need Mental Health Care, Leading Irish Psychiatrist Says
- 14-Year-Olds to Learn about Their “Right” to an Abortion
- Sky’s Suicide Broadcast “Indefensible”
- Vatican Raps Italy’s Abortion-Pill Plan; More Doctors Refuse to Kill
- More Adult Stem-Cell Progress: Brain Cells “Could Restore Hearing”
- Why the Right to Life is Precious—Tales from an Irish Gran
- Profit Motivates Embryo Stem-Cell Research, Irish Bishop Alleges
- UK Bishops Hail Promising New Adult Stem-Cell Treatments
- Vatican Warns Against Moral Pitfalls of Biotechnology
- UN Rights Declaration Inspires a Country to Promote the Family